Publisher's Weekly Review
New Yorker foreign correspondent Hessler (Oracle Bones) lived in Egypt during the months and years following the 2011 ouster of president Hosni Mubarak, and his account of learning Arabic, befriending a diverse array of characters, and gingerly probing the sore spots of Egyptian society is at once engrossing and illuminating. While Hessler lives in Cairo and much of the early action centers there, he ventures more widely than most foreigners in the country, and his reporting from sleepy upper Egyptian villages and remote Chinese development projects add complexity. Most of Hessler's contacts get roughed up and imprisoned by the security services at one point or another, often for inscrutable reasons: "There was no point to the brutality-it served no larger purpose." He returns frequently to the theme of internal tension and contradiction-that Egyptians "combined rigid tradition with ideas that could be surprisingly open-minded or nonconformist"-to contrast the brittle institutions of the state, such as courts, with the deep-seated social patterns and relationships that provide structure when the state is dysfunctional or ineffectual. Adroitly combining the color and pacing of travel writing and investigative journalism with the tools and insight of anthropological fieldwork and political theory, this stakes a strong claim to being the definitive book to emerge from the Egyptian revolution. (May) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Kirkus Review
The New Yorker staff writer recounts five years of work as a correspondent in Egypt, where he witnessed the events of the so-called Cairo Spring.The great struggle of Egypt, suggests Hessler (Strange Stones: Dispatches from East and West, 2013, etc.) over the course of this long but economically written study, is both to forge a national identity and to enter historythe history that one can record accurately, that is. On the second matter, the author looks deeply into the Egyptian past and the pharaonic notion that the past is never even past but instead "exists forever in the present." It would also seem to be open to interpretation; Hessler opened a textbook to find that, as if by miracle, Egypt won the October War of 1973, which "actually ended with the Egyptian Third Army surrounded by the Israelis." So it is that Egyptian museums display but don't really interpret the past, even as that textbook noted, in passing, "Whoever has no history has no present." All of these ponderings have bearing on what Hessler witnesses on the streets of Cairo and surrounding small towns as Islamists battle modernist reformers and members of the old post-Nasserite regime, each with a different view of what it means to be an Egyptianin some instances of which former "fellaheen," or "peasants," actually claim descent not from the pharaohs but instead from the Saudis across the Red Sea. Hessler's interlocutors are a fascinating lot, including a garbage collector who ports away his own empty bottles of beer after visits, knowing he's going to have to do so anyway, and an Arabic-language instructor with a subtle command of politics. In the chaos of the revolution, some of those interlocutors are forced to leave, finding exile in faraway lands.Nuanced and deeply intelligenta view of Egyptian politics that sometimes seems to look at everything but and that opens onto an endlessly complex place and people. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Archaeology is the science of interpreting a distant past without being misled by one's familiar present. Hessler (Strange Stones, 2013) conveys the near-impossibility of this challenge as he recounts his five years of reporting on the crisis of Egypt's Arab Spring while studying the mysteries of the land's ancient ruins. Hessler's inability to transcend his cultural biases and his condescending reduction of Egyptians in amusing anecdotes is grating, yet he has the self-awareness to recognize the West's childlike romanticization of Egypt in himself and his Western colleagues. The similarity between archaeology and politics, both involving a series of revelations and obfuscations, is made clear by Hessler's juxtaposition of seemingly disparate events. After the ousting of Mubarak and the ascension of Morsi, a portrait of the former leader disappears and is replaced by one of the new leader. Nothing else seems to change. Likewise, an American archaeological team excavates a tomb, then reburies it for the sake of preservation, leaving no trace. Whether in modern Egypt under the Muslim Brotherhood or the ancient Egypt of the pharaohs, all is cyclical.--Lesley Williams Copyright 2019 Booklist
New York Review of Books Review
CONVICTION, by Denise Mina. (Mulholland, $27.) Anna McDonald, at loose ends while her philandering husband takes their children on vacation, decides to clear an old friend's name after hearing him slandered on a true-crime podcast. Mina's incredible new mystery seems to have been written in a white-hot rage. THE GUARDED GATE: Bigotry, Eugenics, and the Law That Kept Two Generations of Jews, Italians, and Other European Immigrants Out of America, by Daniel Okrent. (Scribner, $32.) In 1920s America, a mix of nativist sentiment and pseudoscience led to the first major law curtailing immigration. Okrent focuses on eugenics, which argued that letting in people of certain nationalities and races would harm America's gene pool. FALL; OR, DODGE IN HELL, by Neal Stephenson. (Morrow/HarperCollins, $35.) Stephenson tackles big questions - what is reality? how might it be simulated? - via the tale of a billionaire whose mind survives in the digital world long after his physical death. A THOUSAND SMALL SANITIES: The Moral Adventure of Liberalism, by Adam Gopnik. (Basic Books, $28.) This charming and erudite book challenges both authoritarian populists and illiberal leftists, arguing in favor of a liberal tradition that supports both social progress and individual liberty. LAST DAY, by Domenica Ruta. (Spiegel & Grau, $27.) Ruta's darkly glittering novel flits among characters - including a trio of astronauts, a 15-year-old girl and a tattoo artist - during the planet's final hours. Despite the heavy subject matter, comic moments leaven the book, and Ruta sprinkles in startling observations. THE BODY IN QUESTION, by Jill Ciment. (Pantheon, $24.95.) In this deliciously acerbic and intelligent novel, two jurors meet at a murder trial, and, sequestered at an Econo Lodge, begin a passionate affair with unexpected reverberations on their lives and the legal proceedings. Among the book's other pleasures, Ciment knowingly but matter-of-factly depicts class distinctions. THE way THE WAY WE EAT NOW: How the Food Revolution Has we eat now Transformed Our Lives, Our Bodies, and Our World, by Bee Wilson. (Basic Books, $30.) In this useful and informative book, a British journalist delves into the ways globalization has revolutionized our relationship THE BURIED: An Archaeology of the Egyptian Revolution, by Peter Hessler. (Penguin Press, $28.) In stories of everyday life in Cairo, Hessler captures a country looking to make sense of what the Arab Spring has wrought. MIND FIXERS: Psychiatry's Troubled Search for the Biology of Mental Illness, by Anne Harrington. (Norton, $27.95.) Harrington argues that the "biological revolution," which rejects Freud to seek a physical basis for mental illness, has overreached. The full reviews of these and other recent books are on the web: nytimes.com/books
