Publisher's Weekly Review
In this insightful group memoir, a reading group of four English professors from the College of New Jersey tackles four Toni Morrison novels: Beloved, The Bluest Eye, A Mercy, and Song of Solomon. Each contributing a pair of essays, they consider African-American history, personal experiences, and Morrison's lessons for the present moment. Jackson interprets The Bluest Eye as a critique of the "strong black woman" cultural trope, while Brown-Glaude finds in Song of Solomon "models of resistance from which we can learn... today." Bennett muses on his outsider position as the volume's one white contributor through Beloved's "brief representation of a comic white girl," and Williams reflects on A Mercy's exploration of the costs of "being seen" through her own memory of "being the only black kid in a sea of" white high school students. She then fittingly concludes the collection with a piece that merges the personal, literary, historical, and contemporary, as she visits the National Museum of African American History and Culture and feels, while viewing Harriet Tubman's shawl, the "epiphanal blackness" also present in Morrison's work. For book lovers and history buffs, as well as the politically engaged, this collection, though small in size, will yield vast intellectual riches. (Feb.)
Kirkus Review
Toni Morrison's novels elicit powerful feelings of fear, grief, and anger.Friends and colleagues at the College of New Jersey, Bennett (Toni Morrison and the Queer Pleasure of Ghosts, 2014, etc.), Brown-Glaude (Higglers in Kingston: Women's Informal Work in Jamaica, 2011, etc.), Jackson (Violence, Visual Culture, and the Black Male Body, 2010, etc.), and Williams (co-editor: Representing Segregation: Toward an Aesthetics of Living Jim Crow, 2012) gathered informally for several years to discuss the novels of the iconic Nobel laureate: "Morrison is our griot, a singer and social commentator, the keeper of traditions and the exemplary engaged citizen of our world." Black and white, three women and one man, all parents anxious about their children's futures, they discovered that Morrison's works spoke to each of them directly, helping them to understand what it means to be black in America and to "live whole in times of uncertainty." To structure the conversations conveyed in this insightful group memoir, they agreed to focus on four novelsThe Bluest Eye, Song of Solomon, Beloved, and A Mercyassigning each to two writers to show how the same novel affects different readers. Besides offering close, fresh readings of Morrison's narratives, the authors share personal stories about the experiences that have shaped them as readers. Bennett, for example, grew up knowing he was an anomaly in his racist military and law enforcement family. Reading Song of Solomon, he writes, gave him a "feeling of floating outside myself" that allowed him "to feel comfortable as an outsider." Jackson, writing about Beloved, and Brown-Glaude, about Song of Solomon, reveal their fears as mothers, consumed by worry about how to keep a child safe in a world where so many unarmed young black people have been killed by police. "My fear is borne out of the unpredictability of those deaths," Brown-Glaude writes. "And my fear, at times, turns to anger toward those mothers of white sons who do not have to live this way."Intimate responses to fiction cohere into a moving meditation on race. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Scholars Bennett, Brown-Glaude, Jackson, and Williams commune through this collection of personal essays examining the brilliance and relevance of Toni Morrison's classic works. They dissect how The Bluest Eye (1970), Beloved (1987), A Mercy (2008), and Song of Solomon (1977) help readers navigate issues that still plague current society. Across themes like the protectiveness of black motherhood, mental health within the black community, xenophobia, and the Black Lives Matter movement, they delve into Morrison's words and the words of those left out in the margins. The authors share experiences that have shaped the way they see the world, with writing that's crisp and direct and with a level of vulnerability that is not only commendable but heartwarming. They do not shy away from uncomfortable truths Morrison's work explores, such as the racist over-sexualization of black bodies or the absurdity of racism as a performance, experienced via white characters Morrison encourages readers to laugh at. This book is an intimate view into the audience Morrison wrote for, as well as the hopeful future she wrote towards. It is a beautiful homage to Morrison's legacy, and a light on all the work there is left to do.--LaParis Hawkins Copyright 2020 Booklist
Library Journal Review
In 2015, college professor friends Bennett (Toni Morrison and the Queer Pleasure of Ghosts), Winnifred Brown-Glande (Higglers in Kingston: Women's Informal Work in Jamaica), Cassandra Jackson (Violence, Visual Culture, and the Black Male Body), and Piper Kendrix Williams (Representing Segregation: Toward an Aesthetics of Living Jim Crow), who form a diverse group of black and white, gay and straight, immigrant and American-born, gathered together and created the Toni Morrison Book Club. After two years of meetings, they crafted this personal work celebrating Morrison's most memorable novels, including The Bluest Eye, Beloved, Song of Solomon, and A Mercy. Here, an aspect of Morrison's writings becomes a catalyst for discussions on police brutality, immigration, xenophobia, mothering, and exoticizing black female bodies, with intimate, moving, and often funny essays evoking a thoughtfulness and honesty on the part of the authors that in turn is demanded from readers. VERDICT All who pick up this book, from Morrison devotees to newcomers, will discover lessons in the literature to apply to their own lives. They will also feel inspired and wish to be part of a Toni Morrison Book Club of their own.--Stefanie Hollmichel, Univ. of St. Thomas Law Lib., Minneapolis
