Kirkus Review
Haley Hancock has been texting Martin Nathaniel Munroe II on the dailybut which Martin is it?Born just a few days apart, both Martin N. Munroe IIs are named after their famously wealthy grandfather. Haley is confident she knows which Martin is the good one because the other one broke her friend's heart in the eighth grade. One of the Martins begins texting her outside of the history class all three share, and over time, both are surprised to find their banter enjoyable and comforting. But, believing her negative opinions of one cousin will hinder their friendship, Haley decides to stop messaging him. In response, Martin proposes a solution: start over with a clean slate as if they were strangers who met on the internet. By connecting only via cellphone, Haley and Martin find it easy to be honest and vulnerable about all aspects of their lives, including family and friends. The two open up to each other about questions of sexual orientation, and Haley also confides in Martin about her generalized anxiety disorder. Told entirely in chat conversations, the potentially perplexing narrative will be understood by readers who are accustomed to communicating online and reading deeply into text messages. The format does not make space for physical descriptions, and most characters are assumed white.Johnson's clever debut speaks to Generation Z's cyberculture by validating online friendships. (Fiction. 12-18) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Debut novelist Johnson experiments with format in this YA romance, told exclusively in text messages. You would think that when high-school junior Haley receives a text message out of the blue from Martin Nathaniel Munroe II, it would be a pretty straightforward exchange. The problem is there are two Martin Nathaniel Munroe IIs in her grade. Haley assumes it's the other Martin, and Martin doesn't know at first that Haley thinks he's the wrong one. When Martin finally realizes the mix-up, it might be too late to come clean about who he really is and express his true feelings for Haley. As the entire novel is an exchange between just two people, readers may be playing catch-up to discern what has happened in between texts. The incorporation of other voices (or texters) could have helped flesh out the story more, and the only narrative conflict (a missed or canceled meeting IRL) is overused. Even so, this is an accessible format for reluctant readers.--Caitlin Kling Copyright 2019 Booklist
