Publisher's Weekly Review
Austin is used to being the new kid in class; along with his mother, the presumed-white fourth grader has moved so many times that he has developed strategies to stay under the radar and to conceal his trouble reading ("If you turn the pages too fast, teachers notice"). On his first day at a new school, Austin meets blue-eyed, effervescent classmate Bertie, who encourages him to apply to Safety Squad. Taciturn Austin relishes the idea of helping younger kids "on the bus and off the bus with their huge backpacks and their shoebox projects," and though he imagines doing the job with easy confidence, he can't bring himself to ask his unpredictable and avoidant mom to sign the permission slip. Austin's narration is conversational and observant, threaded with descriptive colors and metaphors that hint at his learning obstacles: "It wasn't like I could tell her that the words started to look like bricks, and the letters started to look like ants, and then the ants turned into dead leaves that were shriveled up with the edges all curling." Swender's (Solving for M) brief, textured tale never spells out the extent of Austin's reading difficulty, while his vigilant protection of his secret and near constant anxiety at it being discovered imbues this thoughtful character study with tension and drive. Ages 9--12. Agent: Jennifer Weltz, Jean V. Naggar Literary. (Nov.)
Horn Book Review
Fourth grader Austin, who has dyslexia, is used to starting at new schools, due to his single mother's frequent moves, but his first day at this one is a surprise. His teacher, Ms. G., is especially welcoming; he doesn't have to do the dreaded "introduction" for his classmates; and he's immediately taken under the wing of the extremely talkative Bertie. Austin tentatively reciprocates her friendship but remains concerned that his mother will decide to relocate at any moment, especially if the school takes note of his learning difficulties. As he settles in, Austin hopes to become a Safety, one of the yellow-vested fifth graders who act as crossing guards and hallway monitors -- but first he has to pass the Safety test, which requires him to do some reading. The characters drive this story more than the plot does. Austin is a fully realized protagonist, and Swender gives readers many paths into his thoughts -- his conversations with his phone's voice-activated assistant, his discovery of Bridge to Terabithia, his tendency to identify colors by the exact names of the crayons in his box. The story will appeal to fans of quiet books who appreciate moments of growth and realistically happy endings. Sarah Rettger January/February 2022 p.124(c) Copyright 2022. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Booklist Review
Austin is used to being the new kid at school. Whenever his mom feels overwhelmed by life, they pull up stakes and resettle. He knows the drill--how he'll be introduced, the curious stares from teachers and classmates, even how lunch will taste. More important, he knows what he must do to protect his secret, because, though already at the end of fourth grade, he struggles with reading. This time, however, his new school is different. His teacher doesn't treat him like an extra burden, he is welcomed enthusiastically by talkative Bertie, and even unpredictable Dee turns out to be more friend than foe. Panic arises when Austin decides he wants to apply for a coveted spot on the fifth-grade Safety Squad, which includes taking a written test. How will he manage it? Throughout this short but spot-on story, readers will discover Austin's toolbox of methods to get through each day, illustrating just how clever he is. This tale tugs heartstrings and brings a deeper understanding of differently abled students.
School Library Journal Review
Gr 3--7--After more moves than he can count, Austin has learned how to blend in at a new school. Get someone to read the back cover of the book to you, so you can pretend you've read it. Write your name neat and tiny, because that's what all the smart kids do. Fake a coughing fit if you're called on to read aloud, because the teacher isn't going to deny you a drink of water. Austin doesn't want to cause any problems, and he doesn't want his teachers to cause him any problems. But things are pretty different when Austin moves to his newest school shortly before summer vacation. For one thing, his teacher seems much cooler than what he's used to. For another, he meets Bertie--an energetic and enthusiastic classmate who is determined to help Austin navigate this new environment, whether he needs help or not. Bertie is super excited to join the school's Safety Squad next year as a fifth grader, and Austin thinks that sounds cool, too. But you have to take a test on the rules to become a Safety Squad member, and that's something Austin can't fake. This middle grade novel provides an insider's perspective on what it's like to be a student with learning difficulties. Austin's coping mechanisms for getting through school work, and other activities that require reading, will be something struggling learners and reluctant readers can relate to. Additionally, Austin's frequent descriptions of the colors in his everyday life provide vivid imagery for readers. VERDICT A great addition to middle grade realistic fiction collections; hand this book to readers who have enjoyed Gary D. Schmidt's Okay for Now or Jacqueline Woodson's Harbor Me.--Alison Glass, Dwight School Lib., New York, NY
Kirkus Review
Moving and changing schools frequently has allowed fourth grader Austin to conceal his inability to read--and prevented him from getting help. Austin's a large kid (repeating second grade didn't help): shy, socially awkward, but quietly observant. Changing schools isn't easy, but he's learned what to expect, what's expected of him, and how to handle it. Initially unresponsive when Bertie--a small, friendly classmate--appoints herself his guide, he slowly warms to her and the school while hiding his inability to decode letters that wave and wobble across the page. His ingenious workarounds include querying the "phone lady" (digital assistant) on his mom's old phone, who answers questions and gives him a link to the audiobook he's supposed to read. At school Austin's especially impressed by the Safety Squad, a select cadre of fifth graders. Bertie encourages him to join. But how can he complete the application without disclosing his disability? While self-contained Austin projects the stoic resignation of children who've learned not to depend on adults, his troubled mom never comes into focus; how she supports them and why they move so frequently go unexplained. The parameters of Austin's disability (or disabilities) are unclear. If his backstory is frustratingly thin, however, Austin himself is a fully realized character whose predicament, true and false assumptions, and choices ring true from beginning to end. Characters mostly present White; naming conventions suggest a diverse classroom. Compellingly conveys the experience of living with an invisible, stigmatized disability. (Fiction. 8-12) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Excerpts
Razzmatazz Pacific Blue The first day you show up at a new school, some teachers give the person bringing you in a real earful. They say something like "Don't you see how many I've got in here?" Then they make a face and look you up and down. One teacher pointed at me and made an outline of me in the air. Like I was so big, where was she going to put me? I have a right-before-the-school-year-starts birthday, so whatever age everybody's turning that year, I've already turned it before the year's even gotten started. Plus, one time when we moved, they made me do second grade a second time. But this teacher didn't point at me when I showed up at the door. She didn't roll her eyes and breathe out sharp like I was the last thing she needed that day. She smiled, and I don't even think it was a fake grown-up smile. "Welcome," she said. "I'm Ms. G." She wasn't one of those young teachers who try too hard to be your best friend, but she didn't seem like one of those old-fashioned, super-strict ones, either. She looked like just a normal teacher, except that she was tall, tall, tall. She was maybe the tallest teacher I'd ever had. Even I had to look up to really see her. The kids were sitting all curled over their desks like a bunch of fiddlehead ferns. Maybe they were taking a test. That's one of the only good things about your first day at a new school. If there's a test, most teachers will say "Oh, don't worry about this. You weren't here when we learned it." She pointed to a desk smack-dab in the middle of the checkerboard room. I would rather have a back-row desk or at least an on-the-edge desk, but this was the only empty one, except for a seat way up at the front, where everyone could see you all the time, and I definitely didn't want that. On top of the desk was a book. Its cover was bright pink and shiny, and on top of all the razzmatazz, a bunch of numbers were floating out of some kid's head. Math. Good. It was the kind of book with pages you can write in. Most teachers barely ever really check them. They just glance them over to see if all the blanks are full. "Page one hundred and seventy-eight," she whispered to me. Almost the end of the book because it was almost the end of the year. The last school told my mom we should maybe wait to move, that it would be better for me to "finish out the term." But my mom said it was time for us to go, even if it was the beginning of June. "Need a pencil?" Ms. G. asked next. I nodded. Don't bring anything in until your second day at a new school. You have to see what kind of class you're in so you don't stick out too much. And if you think at least a pencil would be a safe bet, you'd be surprised. I was in one place where everybody got their own laptop and another one that used these old-fashioned mini-chalkboards. You don't want to be the only kid holding a pencil when everybody else has a piece of chalk. But this seemed like your basic pencil class. She handed me one that was long and new and still had a full eraser. And when she turned to walk away, I saw she had about five more, pointing in all different directions through her ponytail. The back of her head looked like some kind of flying sea urchin. I sat down and bent over my desk like everybody else. The math was easy. I looked at the numbers, and the answers showed up. Even if it's supposed to be letters that tell you things loud and clear, numbers talk to me a lot louder. I finished the page and went on to the next one. I didn't know if we were supposed to, but I never met a teacher who got mad and upset because a kid did more pages than they were supposed to do. The next page had some wordy problems, though. I watched the letters moving from one line to the next. But before I could worry about which blanks looked like they wanted letter-answers, and which blanks looked like they wanted number-answers, the teacher rang a little bell. It was the kind you ding at a store counter when you need somebody to help you--round and silver and very shiny. The kids closed their books and put them away. I did, too. I'm good at following directions. If you don't give teachers any problems, nine times out of ten, they won't give you any problems. Then I realized what was coming next--The Introduction. The teacher would say she had an announcement to make. She'd tell everybody my name and that they should be welcoming to me. Then she would ask me to say a few words about myself, like what I enjoyed doing in my free time and why my family had moved. I have a couple of speeches all made up and memorized. I always say my hobby is snorkeling. It's the kind of hobby that could be normal where we used to live but is really hard to do here. And it's not the kind of hobby that a lot of people have and then want to talk about. I never met another kid who said, "Oh, you're a snorkeler? Hey! Me too!" Then I say we moved either because my dad got a new job or because my mom wants to be closer to her sister who is "quite ill." I can do these introductions so well, even I half believe them. "I have an announcement," the teacher said. Told you. And even though I've done The Introduction, like, a million times, I still get that feeling. I don't understand why people call it "butterflies in your stomach." Butterflies are happy and colorful and free, and this feeling is none of those things. This feeling is spiky and tricky, and it stings. I call it "yellow jackets in your stomach." But all she said was: "Time for lunch." Huh. I stood up and walked to where I thought the line would be. But the kids were still hanging around, like they were waiting for something. "Okay," the teacher finally said. "Alphabetical order by first name." I didn't get it. "And by the way," she added, "our new friend's name is Austin." A short girl with big glasses came right up to me. She showed me a smile all railroad-tracked with braces and stuck out her hand to shake mine. "Hi," she said. "I'm Bertie." I didn't say anything. I just shook her hand and nodded a little. I mean, I didn't really shake her hand--more like I squeezed her fingers for a second. "You're first," Bertie said. "Because you're A and I'm B. Except for Bodhi, but he's B-O." She slapped her palm to her forehead and giggled. "I mean, he's not B.O. His name starts with B-O and mine starts with B-E, and E comes before O, but you knew that already." I scooted around her to get to the front of the line. It was kind of cool to be the kid standing in the doorway with a view into the hall. This school had very shiny floors. "My real name is Beatrice." Bertie was still right behind me. "But I don't like being called Bea because I don't like bees. I'm not allergic or anything. I just don't like them." Bertie's words were buzzy like bees, but not like yellow jackets in your stomach. They were more like those puffy bumblebees just flying around, looking for a flower or something. "Do you have any nicknames?" I shook my head no. "Well, it's nice to meet you, Austin." She smiled all the way back to the rubber bands on her braces, which made one side of her face squish down more than the other. But her eyes were still twinkly-crinkly, and her braces were a cool-blue color, like pacific blue. Still doesn't mean I smiled back. Pacific Blue Outrageous Orange I followed the teacher to the cafeteria. I was glad she was in front of me because I had no idea where I was going. I think all the schools should get together and decide to build themselves the same way. Then you'd always know where the cafeteria was. "Mission control to Austin. Mission control to Austin." Bertie was still behind me. She made a noise like static on a walkie-talkie. "You need a tray. And a milk." I picked up a tray. I picked up a milk. "Now slide down toward the main course," Bertie said. She used her tray to push mine along the little track. Bertie was acting like she thought I'd never, ever been in a lunch line before, or that this school's lunch line was somehow way different from every other lunch line. Or maybe she was just the kind of kid who really liked being a helper. "Spaghetti or sandwich?" the lunch server asked me. "Now you say if you want spaghetti or a sandwich," Bertie whispered into my arm. I think she was trying to whisper it into my ear, but I'm that much bigger than she is. You could fit about a hundred Berties into a classroom and still have plenty of space when someone brought a big new kid to the door. "That's the spaghetti." Bertie pointed to the spaghetti. "And that's Chef Gail." She pointed to a woman in a chef's hat, stirring a big pot. "Hi, Chef Gail!" Bertie called. "Hi there, Bertie!" the woman called back. "Um, spaghetti, please," I said. "You new, sweetie?" the server asked me. She scooped a big pile of spaghetti onto my plate and ladled on the sauce. A lot of schools are stingy with the spaghetti, or the sauce is all gloppy and cold. But this looked pretty good. "Yes, Ms. Jackie," Bertie said. "This is Austin." "Welcome, Austin," Ms. Jackie said, and she handed my plate across the counter. "Don't forget your bread and fruit." "He won't forget," Bertie said. I didn't care so much about Bertie answering all the first-day questions for me. It made it easier to keep track of things. I picked up some bread. I picked up some fruit. Now, most schools have another person at the end of the tray track, who you pay unless you get free lunch. And when that person waves you through with a little phhhp sound, like the air escaping out of a hole in a balloon, everybody knows you get free lunch. But when I got to the end of the track, nobody was there. "That's our table." Bertie pointed with her chin. And even though she stayed behind me the whole time, she steered me to the right place. She reminded me of this cute dog my mom and I saw at the fair last summer. It held back and kind of nosed at the air, but it still got all these baby ducks over the little bridge and into the kiddie pool without ever touching them. "Slide down to the end," Bertie said, "on account of the fact that you're the line leader. Then I'm next. Then Bodhi. Then Carlos. Then Charlene. Then David A. Then David C. Then Destiny. Then George. And so on and so on." This seemed like a good spot. There was only Bertie on one side of me and nobody else on the other side of me. Across the table were two girls sitting so close together, it looked like they shared the same hair. I didn't think I had to worry about not talking to them. If you don't talk to the other kids too much, pretty soon they'll stop talking to you. "Mia and Nia," Bertie said. "They love it when we line up in alphabetical order by first name. They're, like, best, best friends. I don't really have a best, best friend. I'm just equal friends with everybody, you know what I mean? But tomorrow we'll line up a different way, like favorite color in the spectrum or birthday." I looked around the cafeteria. I figured this school must have a rule about not getting up once you sit down. Some places, kids are always getting up--they want an extra packet of ketchup, or they forgot to get a milk. You never know if getting up is really allowed, or if the teachers just get tired of telling everybody to sit down. "I'm always line leader when we line up by birthday," Bertie said. "January second. Unless you're January first. So when's your birthday?" Bertie stopped talking long enough to take a bite of spaghetti. She opened her milk while she chewed. She looked at me from behind her big glasses, and her eyes were so open, it felt like I couldn't not tell her. "August--" I said. "Let me guess!" she said. "August fourth!" "Uh, no," I said. Bertie squeezed one eye shut like she was thinking about it real hard as she peeled her clementine. "Is it the twenty-ninth?" she shouted, all excited. "Because if it is, it depends on what time you were born because David A. is also August twenty-ninth, but he wasn't born until twelve minutes before midnight, so chances are you'd still be ahead of him." I looked down at my spaghetti. I wasn't sure how I'd gotten into this whole conversation. Maybe if I told Bertie the answer, she would stop talking to me. But when I looked up, Bertie's pacific blue smile had suddenly turned, like, outrageous orange. She'd taken the peel from her clementine and stuck it over her teeth. I almost smiled at that. "Five-minute warning, Ms. G.'s class," someone called from the head of the table. It wasn't a teacher. It was a kid wearing this weird yellow thing that crossed from her shoulder to a belt around her waist. It looked like she had a big, bright greater-than sign across herself. In all the schools I'd been to, I'd never seen a kid wearing a big, bright greater-than sign across themselves. "That's Kayla," Bertie said, pulling the orange peel out of her mouth. "She's our lunch Safety." I didn't know what Bertie was talking about, but I didn't want to get into a whole other conversation about it. I took a few more bites of spaghetti and a last swig of milk. Some school food is pretty yuck, but this was a good lunch. I wondered if they ever let you get seconds. "You're still the line leader," Bertie said, and she stuck with me the whole way, telling me where to put my tray and my garbage and where to line up. "It's round-trip employment, unless you get sick or you have to go to the bathroom or something. One time, Carlos suddenly got sick, so the second-in-line had to step in. You don't feel like you're going to throw up, do you?" Excerpted from Stuck by Jennifer Swender All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.
